Next Mob

« Grokster: Congress and the Courts | Main | Regulate the Internet? »

June 27, 2005

Lichtman: Hollow Victory in Grokster

MGM won on paper today, but my first reading of the opinion makes me wonder whether the victory will have any bite outside of this specific litigation. Intent-based standards, after all, are among the easiest to avoid. Just keep your message clear -- tell everyone that your technology is designed to facilitate only authorized exchange -- and you have no risk of accountability.

That is not the standard I was hoping for. As I wrote in the amicus brief, I would have allowed liability to be based exclusively on objective evidence, for example a party's failure to alter its technology in a way that would significantly reduce infringing behavior without significantly interfering with legitimate.

The Court closed the door on this sort of inquiry, however. As the opinion makes clear, evidence of unreasonable product design can be considered only if there is also smoking-gun evidence of intent. Indeed, even outlandish design desicions are off limits without the relevant precursor.

Surely the Court realizes that well-advised bad actors rarely leave smoking guns lying about. Hence the victory here looks hollow, and in my view the legal rule seems poorly crafted.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/426934/2720358

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Lichtman: Hollow Victory in Grokster:

» Grokster Loses - Unanimously - Inducement Test? from The Importance of...
via SCOTUS BlogThe Supreme Court ruled unanimously that developers of software violate federal copyright law when they provide computer users with the means to share music and movie files downloaded from the internet.The decision when it appears. Unani... [Read More]

» Supremes: 9-0 Against Grokster from The TechLaw Weblog
The Supreme Court ruled unanimously in favor of movie studio, recording labels and other copyright industries in MGM v Grokster today. The Court ruled that a copyright infringement against Grokster and StreamCast can go forward. But this may prove... [Read More]

» Grokster: A Hollow Victory? from The Listless Lawyer
Grokster: A Hollow Victory?. Professor Solem also points to footnote 12, which says: Of course, in the absence of other evidence of intent, a court would be unable to find contributory infringement liability merely based on a failure to take af... [Read More]

» Grokster Loses - Unanimously - Inducement Test? from The Importance of...
via SCOTUS BlogThe Supreme Court ruled unanimously that developers of software violate federal copyright law when they provide computer users with the means to share music and movie files downloaded from the internet.The decision when it appears. Unani... [Read More]

» MGM v. Grokster -- What Happened? from Copyfight
Here's the ruling itself [PDF], finding that "one who distributes a device with the object of promoting its use to infringe copyright, as shown by the clear expression or other affirmative steps taken to foster infringement, is liable for the... [Read More]

» Grokster Loses - Unanimously - Inducement Test? from The Importance of...
via SCOTUS BlogThe Supreme Court ruled unanimously that developers of software violate federal copyright law when they provide computer users with the means to share music and movie files downloaded from the internet.The decision when it appears. Unani... [Read More]

» Blogosphere weighs in on Grokster ruling from Darknet
As expected from the most important copyright case of the digital age, there's much discussion in the blogosphere this morning about the Supreme Court's Grokster decision today. Here's a sampling of some highlights: • The SCOTUS ruling itself, in PDF... [Read More]

» Grokster Loses - Unanimously - Inducement Test? from The Importance of...
via SCOTUS BlogThe Supreme Court ruled unanimously that developers of software violate federal copyright law when they provide computer users with the means to share music and movie files downloaded from the internet.The decision when it appears. Unani... [Read More]

» Grokster Loses - Unanimously - Inducement Test? from The Importance of...
via SCOTUS BlogThe Supreme Court ruled unanimously that developers of software violate federal copyright law when they provide computer users with the means to share music and movie files downloaded from the internet.The decision when it appears. Unani... [Read More]

» Grokster Ruling Commentary from Technology & Marketing Law Blog
In this post, I'll summarize some of the various blog reactions I read. You should start with my own, of... [Read More]

» Grokster Ruling Commentary from Technology & Marketing Law Blog
In this post, I'll summarize some of the various blog reactions I read. You should start with my own, of... [Read More]

» MGM vs Grokster: and the winner is . . . from Kairosnews

The US Supreme Court ruled today in MGM vs Grokster. While the court ruled in favor of MGM, the ruling is not the death of P2P that many might thought it would be. As Justics Souter explains in [Read More]

» To Grok Or Not To Grok from the horse
It's been a banner week for the good ol' Supreme Court, finishing off their term on Monday with a nice hefty wad of decisions. You all know which one I was waiting for , and it came down looking like... [Read More]

» To Grok Or Not To Grok from the horse
It's been a banner week for the good ol' Supreme Court, finishing off their term on Monday with a nice hefty wad of decisions. You all know which one I was waiting for , and it came down looking like... [Read More]

Comments

I think that the point made by the court may have been missed; until the concept, and reality, of such technologies is furthered, it is premature for the court to make any long term decisions. The court said, to paraphrase; "Yes, these companies are wrong, but we're not sure how much more they would have needed to be OK, so we'll pass on the question."

It is extremely unlikely that this will be the last case that goes to the supreme court on filesharing issues, so they have deferred the issue until it is made moot by the continued rush of users to the various services of dubious legality for obviously non-legal purposes.

domai domai domai

my super dragonball

Good site! I'll stay reading! Keep improving!

attendance attendance attendance attendance

barefoot barefoot coral calcium barefoot-corals calcium

very interesting, but I don't agree with you
Idetrorce

plumbaginaceae remiped dint supersensuality muddish semiundressed problematic mulberry
Debian
http://ft-engineering.com/

I love to use what Jimmy D. Brown has coined as the“ useful, but incomplete” approach when using freebies of any kind. (Ezine articles, free eBooks, reports, eCourses, etc.)

http://letsgo.kz lets go kz
http://gamecheatsnew.blogspot.com new game cheats
http://newsspyware.blogspot.com news spyware
http://topcelebrityblogs.blogspot.com top celebrity blogs

http://mycelebrity.wordpress.com my celebrity
http://celebrityclub.wordpress.com celebrity club
http://celebrityhotnews.wordpress.com celebrity hot news
http://sexycelebrity.wordpress.com sexy celebrity

http://mycelebrityclub.blogspot.com My celebrity club
http://topcelebrityblog.blogspot.com top celebrity blog
http://blogcelebritystars.blogspot.com blog celebrity stars
http://bloggercelebrity.blogspot.com blogger celebrity

http://topcelebrityblogs.blogspot.com top celebrity blogs
http://jessica-alba-fan-blog.blogspot.com jessica alba
http://jessica-simpson-fan-blog.blogspot.com jessica simpson
http://jennifer-lopez-fan-blog.blogspot.com jennifer lopez

http://scarlett-johansson-fan-blog.blogspot.com scarlett johansson
http://britney-spears-fan-blog.blogspot.com britney spears
http://parishiltonfanblog.blogspot.com paris hilton
http://linsey-lohan-fan-blog.blogspot.com linsey lohan

http://nicole-kidman-fan-blog.blogspot.com Nicole Kidman
http://eva-longoria-fan-blog.blogspot.com Eva Longoria

http://50-cent-fan-blog.blogspot.com 50 Cent
http://akon-fan-blog.blogspot.com Akon

http://justin-timberlake-fan-blog.blogspot.com Justin Timberlake
http://gwen-stefani-fan-blog.blogspot.com Gwen Stefani
http://kylie-minogue-fan-blog.blogspot.com Kylie Minogue
http://madonna-fanblog.blogspot.com Madonna

http://linkin-park-fan-blog.blogspot.com Linkin Park
http://christina-aguilera-fan-blog.blogspot.com Christina Aguilera
http://pamelaandersonfanblog.blogspot.com Pamela Anderson
http://robbie-williams-fan-blog.blogspot.com Robbie Williams

About Us This community blog has since existed 2 years ago, with the primary focus on HYIP (High Yield Investment Programs) then. Author Jude has a small vision of establishing a community of authors and readers that can form a close niche on passive income from investments. From our time, we've seen..

Coral Calcium: You can build a business where you can be passive and enjoy a good income. Let the company advertise and build it for you.

oecilk gewf ywsdj uyktwjhp qxjibo mrtaljk ywues

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

May 2008

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Blog powered by TypePad